The Differences Between Soy Formula And Organic Hypoallergenic Formula

February 15, 2021 12 min read

The Differences Between Soy Formula And Organic Hypoallergenic Formula

Baby formula is fed to babies as a supplement or replacement of human breast milk. The standard formulas are usually made from cow's milk, and there are specialty formulas which are made for babies that are allergic or have an intolerance to milk. Pediatricians often prescribe hypoallergenic and soy baby formula to babies who have a milk protein allergy and sometimes babies who have a strong family history of allergies.

 

Allergies

Some of the common symptoms of allergies include runny nose, eczema, diarrhea, wheezing and extreme irritability. These symptoms can range from mild to severe and can sometimes even be life-threatening.

Research has shown that only 2% to 3% of babies have milk allergies. While there are many types of special formulas, this article will focus mainly on organic hypoallergenic formula and soy formula. Always remember to consult with your pediatrician before you go for either soy or hypoallergenic formulas.

 

Reasons to choose soy or hypoallergenic formula

Parents opt for soy or hypoallergenic formulas because they contain alternative nutrients that their babies may tolerate better than the proteins or carbohydrates that are contained in cow's milk. It is important that parents consult with their babies' pediatricians before settling for either of these formulas. Depending on each baby's individual needs, parents will be advised to use the formula that suits them best.

Both formulas have their own benefits and setbacks. However, in general, these formulas are given to babies who have a problem digesting cow's milk. These babies should have been diagnosed with either allergies or lactose intolerance and given a recommendation on which kind of baby formula is suitable for them.

Lactose intolerance vs. dairy allergy

But before we get further into this discussion, did you know that lactose intolerance is not the same as milk allergy? It is common for these two terms to be used interchangeably in daily conversations. It is important that you understand the difference between lactose intolerance and milk allergy when choosing the most appropriate type of formula for your baby. Milk allergy and lactose intolerance may indeed have overlapping symptoms, but they are, in fact, very different. Not all children that have milk protein allergy are lactose intolerant, and vice versa.

Lactose intolerance is a digestive problem that may cause discomfort but will not trigger a life-threatening reaction like anaphylaxis. The symptoms of lactose intolerance can be mild or severe depending on the amount of lactose consumed and the tolerated amount. An allergy, on the other hand, might trigger severe symptoms and can cause anaphylaxis. To this end, it is important to note that both soy and hypoallergenic formulas have their places, and they cannot always be used interchangeably.

 

Baby formula

 

SOY BABY FORMULA

Soy baby formula is made from soy protein from soybeans. Soy protein-based formula is fortified by adding vitamins and minerals, including iron and zinc, for it to provide the required nutrition for babies. They do not contain cow's milk protein because it is mainly plant-based. For this reason, many parents use soy protein formula for babies with cow milk allergies. Many parents also switch to soy-based formula when they observe colic, gas, or fussiness in their babies. But are these the right reasons to switch to soy protein formula? This article will discuss soy formula in more detail and determine whether soy is a good option for babies who are intolerant to lactose or whether it helps relieve colic as commonly believed.

 

WHEN SHOULD YOU USE SOY-BASED FORMULA?

Use In Babies With Lactose Intolerance

Soy protein-based formula is most beneficial for infants who are congenitally lactose intolerant. Some babies have digestive systems that are unable to digest lactose in milk. Lactose is the sugar that is found in milk and other dairy products. When you eat food that contains lactose, the lactose is broken down into simple sugars, glucose, and galactose in the small intestines. When there is a lack or deficiency of the enzyme lactase in the small intestines, lactose cannot be digested nor absorbed. The unabsorbed lactose causes discomfort to the baby resulting in severe diarrhea, and the baby is at risk of suffering from severe dehydration and weight loss. In such cases, it is necessary to feed your baby using soy-based formula.

 

Use For Babies With Secondary Lactase Deficiency

It is also often recommended for babies who develop temporary lactase deficiency after suffering from an intestinal infection. It is possible for lactose intolerance to occur temporarily in children. This especially common after a viral infection and conditions that lead to inflammation of the intestines like the celiac disease. This explains why sometimes your doctor will ask you to avoid milk that contains lactose when your baby has a stomach bug. In a study comparing human milk, cow milk-based formula, and soy protein-based formula, there was no difference in the rate of recovery from rotavirus or non-rotavirus diarrhea using nutritional therapy. However, the study observed that for infants who receive soy-protein based formula, the duration of diarrhea was shorter.

 

Use For Vegetarian And Vegan Families

Soy protein-based formula is often preferred by vegetarian parents who wish to raise their babies as vegetarians too. However, the American Academy of Pediatrics cautions against the use of soy-based formula unless it is recommended by a pediatrician.

 

Baby formula

 

CONCERNS ABOUT USING SOY BABY FORMULA

There are reservations about phytates that are found in soy-based formulas. According to the National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences, the phytates bind essential minerals like calcium, phosphorous, iron, and zinc that the baby needs for growth. For this reason, soy-based formulas are often fortified with iron and zinc to improve their quality. Soy-based formulas often have 20% – 30% more calcium content than milk-based formulas to prevent calcium deficiencies and consequent deficiencies in bone mineralization.
 
It is worth noting that more research needs to be done to study the iron and zinc contents in soy-based formula. This is because companies like Isomil's Soy Formula made by Ross Laboratories do not add more iron to their soy protein-based formula than their cow milk formulas. They conducted a study that found that the blood mineral profile of babies fed on soy was no different from that of babies fed on cow's milk formula.

 

Use For Babies With An Allergy To Cow's Milk

According to the American Academy of Pediatricians Committee on Nutrition, 10% to 14% of infants who are allergic to cow's milk are also allergic to soy. For this reason, soy is not the best option for babies who are allergic to cow's milk protein because there are chances that they are also allergic to soy protein. Mothers of children who have clinically diagnosed allergies to cow's milk are usually recommended to use hydrolyzed protein formula.

 

Use In Term And Pre-Term Babies

While research has proven that soy baby formula is safe for term babies, it is not recommended for pre-term babies. Several studies have recorded normal growth and development in term babies who are fed on soy-based formula. However, research has shown a higher rate of osteopenia in pre-term and underweight babies who are fed on soy-based formula. Osteopenia is a condition that is characterized by having weak bones. This is because soy-based formula contains higher levels of aluminum compared to breast milk and cow's milk-based formulas. This aluminum competes with calcium for absorption. There are cow milk-based formulas in the market that are designed for pre-term babies, which should be preferred over soy-based formulas.

 

Using Soy-based Formula For Colic

Many parents switch to soy protein-based formula because they believe it will help relieve colic for their babies. However, there is no evidence showing that soy protein-based formulas help relieve colic. The Committee on Nutrition of the American Academy of Pediatrics recommends against the use of soy-based formulas in the routine management of colic because there is no evidence that soy-based formula helps relieve colic.

 

Severe Reactions To Soy Formula

As with cow milk protein, several studies have documented severe reactions to soy protein-based formula. Several studies have reported inflammation of different parts of the gut resulting in malabsorption. Suppose your baby reacts to soy-based formula as well as cow milk-based formula. In that case, it is advisable that you switch to hydrolyzed protein formulas, of course, in consultation with your pediatrician.

 

Phytoestrogens In Soy Baby Formula

Research by the National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences suggests that girls who are fed on soy-based formula when infants are more likely to suffer severe menstrual pain in adulthood. This is associated with the fact that soy contains phytoestrogen that has an impact on the reproductive system while the babies develop. Phytoestrogens are compounds that are found in beans and other legumes and have the ability to act like the hormone estrogen in the body.

 

Other Concerns

Soy-based formulas contain 33% more sodium than the standard cow's milk-based formula. This is a very high amount of salt for babies as formulas generally are saltier than breastmilk. For this reason, it is not wise to give soy formula unless it is necessary.
Some other concerns around soy formula include the issue that soy proteins lack some amino acids that are crucial for the development of the baby. With improved research, some amino acids are added to some formula brands.

 

The Bottom Line

Are you concerned about the safety of giving your baby soy formula? Well, consult your doctor! It is important to note that after careful investigation in animals, adult humans, and infant populations, experts have expressed minimal concern that soy protein formula may adversely affect human development, reproduction, or endocrine function. Furthermore, all baby formulas sold in the USA are reviewed by the FDA to ensure that they are appropriate for babies in terms of composition, purity, and nutrient content. This means that soy-based formula is safe to use for your baby. However, the health agencies say that soy-based formula should only be used for children who need it. The rest of the children should be fed cow's milk-based formulas for optimal nutrition.

 

Soy formula in Europe

European authorities advise against the use of soy formula, unless medically necessary. This is due to the previously mentioned levels of phytoestrogens, which can act similarly to estrogen and can negatively influence the absorption of minerals. Since the influence of a higher isoflavone intake on babies has not yet been fully analyzed and clarified, but may have effects on reproductive organs and the immune system, for precautionary reasons European authorities and the Nutrition Committee of the German Society for Paediatric and Youth Medicine discourage the use of soy formula. Exceptions should only be made if it is necessary due to medical reasons (e.g. lactase deficiency) or if parents reject cow's milk-based infant formula due to ethical or religious reasons (however a pediatrician should be consulted first).

 

Baby

 

HYPOALLERGENIC FORMULA (Protein Hydrolysate Formula)

Hypoallergenic formula is made from cow's milk. Although they are made from cow's milk, these formulas are processed in such a way that the allergy-causing protein is broken down into smaller compounds that can easily be digested by the baby. The process of breaking down protein into smaller particles (hydrolysis) makes the formula less likely to cause allergies.

 

Types Of Hypoallergenic Formula

These formulas can either be extensively hydrolyzed, partially hydrolyzed, or amino-acid based formula.

Extensively hydrolyzed formulas are those that have broken down the cow's milk protein into to completely small compounds that are easily digestible.


Partially hydrolyzed formulas, on the other hand, break down the cow's milk proteins into larger pieces compared to extensively hydrolyzed formulas. Partially hydrolyzed formulas might help relieve fussiness and gas in some babies, but it might not be good for babies who are allergic to cow's milk as they might still trigger allergies. This means that babies who are very sensitive to cow's milk are better off using extensively hydrolyzed formulas or amino-acid based formulas.


Amino-acid based formulas do not contain any whole protein molecules. They are made of basic amino acids. Amino acids are the building blocks of proteins. They are used when babies are sensitive, even to hydrolyzed formulas. Amino acid-based formulas are the most expensive, but sometimes they are necessary for the well-being of the baby.

 

Baby

 

When Can You Use Hypoallergenic Formula?

Pediatricians recommend this formula for babies with a documented milk protein allergy. The extensively hydrolyzed formula is the best for babies who have milk allergies. Some of these children also tend to have a soy protein allergy, and therefore they cannot take soy-based formula. Always remember to consult your pediatrician before you go for this type of formula. For children who are sensitive to extensively hydrolyzed formulas, amino acid-based formulas are recommended.

 

Organic Hypoallergenic Formula

There is growing concern over the sources of food and the processes employed in the processing of the food. Just like organic food and other organic products, mothers tend to prefer organic formulas. Mothers who are concerned about their babies ingesting pesticide residue or other chemicals that might slip through the formula during manufacturing often insist on organic formula.

However, nutritionists recommend organic formulas for babies with compromised immunity or endocrine dysfunction. Organic formulas are made using certified organic ingredients and processing aids. Organic formulas are GMO-free, and they usually have to comply with the national list of allowed and prohibited substances. This means that certain preservatives and additives that are usually contained in standard formulas cannot be used in organic formulas.

The FDA requires that formulas have certain nutrients and preservatives which can only be created synthetically. Examples of these nutrients include lutein, lycopene, nucleotides, taurine, and L-Carnitine. It is worth noting that some of these ingredients are accepted in the US but are banned in Europe. Experts advise that you go for a formula that has a nutritional profile that is closest to breast milk as possible.



HiPP Hypoallergenic Formula

HiPP is a preferable brand if you are looking for an organic hypoallergenic formula. It contains important prebiotics, omegas 3 and 6 for healthy brain development and immune function, as well as various other vitamins and minerals. It does not contain any additional sugar.

HiPP is also made from organic cow’s milk, which means no pesticides or GMOs. Even though the formula is not technically EU organic certified, all ingredients are still organic and adhere to the strict EU guidelines for organic production. Hypoallergenic formulas unfortunately do not qualify for organic certification, because of the broken-down protein. Due to the hydrolysis, the end product is too far away from its original form – and there is no natural source of broken-down protein.

HiPP is an all-organic German baby formula manufacturer with many decades of experience. It is very popular with European parents and gaining increasing popularity in the US and Canada as well. Next to the EU-Organic certification HiPP has their own Bio label, which ensures that the products are pesticide free.


Homemade Formula

Because of the high cost of organic formulas or other reasons, some mothers resort to making organic homemade formula for their babies. There are quite a number of recipes for organic formula on the internet that some mothers use. However, the American Academy of Pediatrics strongly advises against homemade formulas. According to the American Academy of Pediatrics, it is important for the health of your baby that you give your baby formula that meets FDA's minimum safety and nutritional standards and that is prepared using safe procedures. Homemade formula may seem cheap and healthy, by it might not be safe and not meet the nutritional needs of your baby.

 

Baby

 

Drawbacks of Hypoallergenic Formula

Cost

Hypoallergenic formulas are the most expensive compared to soy and cow milk formulas. This might make it difficult for many families to afford to sustain a baby on hydrolyzed formula. Luckily some insurance covers will help purchase these formulas if there is medical evidence that the baby requires them.

 

Unpleasant Taste

As a result of the intense processing that it undergoes to break down the proteins, the formula can have an unpleasant taste. For this reason, a lot of brands add sugar and cornstarch to make it taste better. These sugars might not be the very best for babies. Hypoallergenic formula should only be used if recommended by a pediatrician.

 

 

Conclusion on Soy and Hypoallergenic Formula

In general, the health agencies advise for babies to be breastfed, but if that is not possible, then milk-based formula is the next best option. However, babies with clinically diagnosed allergies to cow's milk protein are better off taking extensively hydrolyzed formulas. Extensively hydrolyzed formula is made from cow's milk, in a process that completely breaks down the protein molecules into smaller pieces that can be easily digested without triggering allergies for the baby. On the other hand, babies who are intolerant to lactose due to conditions like galactosemia or lactase deficiency can be fed on soy-based formulas, if advised by a pediatrician.

Throughout this article, some major differences between soy formulas and hypoallergenic formulas are highlighted. Firstly, soy protein-based formulas are made from soybeans and therefore contain plant protein, while hypoallergenic formulas are made from cow's milk in a process that predigests the cow's milk protein.

Secondly, soy baby formula contains higher levels of aluminum than hypoallergenic formula, and therefore, it is not suitable for pre-term babies. Thirdly, hypoallergenic formula has a higher success rate of preventing allergies in 90% of the babies, whereas 10% to 14% of the babies that are allergic to cow's milk protein are allergic to soy-based formulas as well. Lastly, soy protein formula is slightly cheaper to buy than hypoallergenic formula.

Please make all your formula decisions in consultation with your doctor. As it has been mentioned several times in this article, these formulas are made for specific needs and have different nutrient profiles. Therefore, it is essential that you get advice from your doctor depending on the specific needs of your child.

 

Baby formula

 

 

References:

  • The American Academy of Pediatrics. https://www.healthychildren.org/English/ages-stages/baby/formula-feeding/Pages/default.aspx
  • Hypoallergenic Infant Formulas, Committee on Nutrition Pediatrics August 2000, 106 (2) 346 349; DOI: https://doi.org/10.1542/peds.106.2.346
  • Use of Soy Protein-Based Formulas in Infant Feeding, Jatinder Bhatia, Frank Greer and ; and the Committee on Nutrition Pediatrics May 2008, 121 (5) 1062-1068; DOI: https://doi.org/10.1542/peds.2008-0564
  • The National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences, https://www.niehs.nih.gov/health/topics/agents/sya-soy-formula/index.cfm

 


Leave a comment

Scroll Up