HiPP vs Holle

Hipp vs. Holle: Baby Formula Comparison 

If you have asked yourself what the differences between HiPP vs. Holle are, this post is for you! After receiving questions about the best formula, we wanted to create an informative list ourselves by comparing two major organic baby food manufacturers from Germany - HiPP vs. Holle. They have been in the formula business for over 50 years while always providing excellent quality. To help you navigate through the differences, we have created this comparison guide: Holle vs. HiPP.

 

HiPP vs. Holle: Formula comparison chart

 

 

Nutrient

HiPP

Holle

Carbohydrates

Many of the formulas are lactose-based

Lactose-based and long-chained organic maltodextrin

Nutrient

Adjusted to mimic breast milk and proteins in special milk formulas are gently processed suitable for sensitive tummies

Adjusted to mimic breast milk and Holle Goat is suitable for cow’s milk intolerances

DHA

According to latest law regulations

According to latest law regulations

Probiotics/Prebiotics

Natural probiotics and prebiotics added (Lactobacillus fermentum hereditum®)

No added prebiotics or probiotics

Organic certification 

Organic according to strict European standards

Demeter quality; biodynamic and the highest organic certification in Europe

Special milk

HiPP HA; HiPP Special Milk, HiPP Anti-Reflux

Organic goat milk formula

 

HiPP vs Holle Ultimate guide

HiPP vs. Holle: Carbohydrates

All pre-formulas are lactose-based. That means the main energy source is lactose and no other carbohydrate, such as starch or maltodextrin, is added. In formulas of higher stages you might come across plant-based maltodextrin, but be assured that their amount is age-appropriate and actually benefits your baby’s energy level, overall development, and ability to sleep through the night. Holle relies mostly on organic long-chained maltodextrin that is also suitable for children with a more sensitive tummy. Therefore, HiPP uses maltodextrin in HiPP Comfort formula for a better digestion.

 

HiPP vs. Holle: Proteins

Proteins in cow’s milk differ to proteins found in breast milk. Especially the ratio of casein proteins and whey proteins differ immensely. Cow milk has about 80% casein and 20% whey, breast milk contains 40% casein and 60% whey. For this reason, you should not feed a baby pure cow milk until they are ready to digest it, which is around 12 months. If you have questions or concerns regarding feeding regular cow’s milk you can talk your pediatrician.

To make cow milk suitable for children, proteins are either removed or broken down. Gentle processing and age-appropriate amounts of protein ensure a formula of excellent quality that makes babies’ tummies happy. To remain close to their holistic philosophy Holle processes their formula as little as possible and if your child does not do well with cow’s milk, the protein ratio in goat’s milk is easier on babies’ tummies. HiPP’s special formula is gently processed to be even less likely to irritate your baby’s digestive system.

 

HiPP vs. Holle: DHA

DHA is an omega-3 fatty acid (LCP) and essential for physical and mental development. The amount of added DHA in formula is regulated by European law. Therefore, there isn’t much of a difference between HiPP vs. Holle. Both, HiPP & Holle use a mix of vegetable and fish oil as the source of omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids.

 

HiPP vs. Holle: Prebiotics & Probiotics

They boost a healthy immune system by helping to build a healthy wall of gut bacteria. They appear naturally in mother’s milk and HiPP’s Lactobacillus fermentum hereditum® was originally derived from real breast milk. Thus, making the formula come as close as possible to breast milk. Holle keeps the list of ingredients short. Therefore, no probiotics and prebiotics are added. However, they can be purchased and easily added to any formula.

 HiPP vs Holle Ultimate comparison

HiPP vs. Holle: Organic certification

All of our formulas are always of organic quality according to strict European law. But if you are looking for a little extra, Holle cow’s milk formula holds the Demeter label, which exceeds conventional organic farming. The holistic, biodynamic approach ensures as little processing as possible. Just as well, HiPP takes the quality of their products and sustainability very serious. Introducing their own organic label, in addition to the European Bio-label, guarantees even better conditions for all beings involved. HiPP’s special milk formulas require a little more processing (breaking down proteins) to make it an easier-to-digest formula. Therefore, they do not formally qualify for the European organic certification.

 

HiPP vs. Holle: Special milk formula

Although regular formula is suitable for most babies, some might need a little extra when frequently struggling with digestive issues. Aware of how nerve wrecking the search for a suitable formula can be, HiPP has introduced multiple formulas for different struggles. HiPP HA, HiPP Anti-Reflux and HiPP Comfort. To meet the needs of babies with an intolerance for cow’s milk, Holle offers a formula made out of goat’s milk. It is the only goat milk formula in organic quality. When it comes to certain intolerances you should consult your pediatrician before switching to a special milk formula.

The bottom line is: both brands are of exceptional quality and geared to the needs of infants. The biggest difference is Holle’s minimal use of ingredients and biodynamic farming methods, whereas HiPP focuses more on designing a formula that comes breast milk as close as possible. It is up to you and your baby’s preferences. No matter which formula you choose, our shop provides you with the best organic baby formula from Europe.

 

We hope this HiPP vs. Holle comparison guide has helped you and if you have further questions please send us an email.